Let's make the state football playoffs fair - The Explorer: Sports

Let's make the state football playoffs fair

Font Size:
Default font size
Larger font size

Posted: Wednesday, December 10, 2008 12:00 am | Updated: 8:02 am, Thu Mar 24, 2011.

“Home, sweet home” always sounds pretty nice.

It has a warm, welcoming ring to it.

Too bad Tucson prep football teams don’t get to hear it often.

Much has been written on the subject of the Phoenix playoff bias during the state playoffs, where Valley teams get to travel mere minutes to a “neutral” site, while Tucson teams ride in uncomfortable buses for hours.

I agree with pretty much everything I’ve read on the matter, with one exception. Numbers are lacking.

I like hard numbers, statistics, and so on; it is my weakness and one of the things that makes sportswriting enjoyable.

And so, good people, here is a quick rundown of what I consider to be an inequality on par with the height difference between Shaq and Danny Devito.

“Neutral” site games begin in the semifinals. Tucson-area teams are reaching this level of competition with increasing frequency, which is why the Valley bias has become more obvious of late.

Take the case of Canyon Del Oro.

Head coach Pat Nugent’s team went 11-1, beating Prescott at home, and Paradise Valley on its own field before facing Scottsdale Chaparral in the 4A-I semifinals. The Dorados lost to the Firebirds 13-7, ending their 2008 campaign.

The game took place at Phoenix North Canyon High School. By the name of the school alone, it is obvious that the Dorados traveled farther that the Firebirds. How much farther?

Well, Chaparral made it through a no-doubt grueling trek of 19 minutes or 12.47 miles, according to Mapquest.com. The Dorados, on the other hand, drove 2 hours, 2 minutes, or almost 130 miles.

A less-hard number would be preparation time: getting the team to school, gear loaded, buses gased, and so on, so tack on another hour, at the least.

However, for argument’s sake, we’ll just work with the hour and forty-five extra minutes the Dorados spent on the road.

What can you do in an hour and forty-five minutes?

How about watch Finding Nemo the whole way through?

Or ordering an appetizer, a well-done steak, and a dessert at a sit-down restaurant?

Those actually sound rather pleasant, but what CDO most likely did in that 1.75 hours was: sit, listen to iPod, look out window. Repeat.

Not so pleasant, and unfair. The stress of the ride is mentally draining to any team.

That doesn’t even mention fan travel time.

Where should CDO and Chaparral have met?

Well, how about Florence High School?

It is 55.99 miles (56 minutes) from CDO and 70 miles (one hour, 14 minutes) from Chaparral.

I’d venture that a difference of 20 minutes is more fair, but should the Scottsdale crowd object, there’s always Globe High School.

The drive is longer for both, one hour and 41 minutes for CDO, one hour and 39 minutes for the Firebirds, but the difference is a scant two minutes.

If one team has to sit on the bus losing steam for nearly two hours, so should the other. It’s as simple as that.

What is wrong with visiting the out-of-the-way towns in search of actual, real neutrality? All are members of the Arizona Interscholastic Association, and as such are readily available for playoff use.

While it will never be known whether time on the road contributed to CDO’s loss, Ironwood Ridge thought the inequity was important enough to call for a change in location, to Chandler High School, for its 5A-II semifinal game against Peoria Centennial. The original site was less that half an hour from Centennial.

Even with the change, the Nighthawks’ drive from Oro Valley to Chandler was still longer than the Coyotes by half on hour. Ironwood Ridge drove one hour and 26 minutes to Centennial’s 55 minutes.

A better location: Casa Grande Union High School, almost smack dab in the middle, an hour and 13 minutes drive for Centennial, one hour for Ironwood Ridge.

I found the suggested sites in about 30 minutes. The AIA has been around for more than 80 years. Granted, the Internet helped me, and that has only been around for about 15 years.

I don’t really think that Tucson schools should separate from the organization like some believe; I’d like to see a Tucson school stick it to the Valley. They should have the chance to do it fairly.

© 2014 The Explorer. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.

Welcome to the discussion.

Kino College

Kino CollegeEnroll today: http://www.kinocollege.com/

HS Schedule

Tuesday, September 16

Boys Golf (@ 3 p.m.)

Buena, Cienega at Marana

Mountain View, Ironwood Ridge, Catalina at Amphi (Silverbell GC)

Catalina Foothills, Pueblo, Sahuarita at Sahuaro

Girls Volleyball (Fr 4 p.m., JV 5 p.m., Var 6 p.m. unless otherwise noted)

Mountain View at Rio Rico

Ironwood Ridge at Glendale Ironwood

Swimming (@4 p.m.)

Pusch Ridge, Sahuarita at Desert Christian

Wednesday, September 17

Girls Golf (@ 3 p.m.)

Rincon at CDO

Ironwood Ridge, Desert View at Flowing Wells (Silverbell)

Cross Country (@4:30)

Salpointe at Catalina Foothills

Palo Verde, Nogales at Marana

Rincon, St. Gregory at CDO

Sahuarita, Pueblo, Pusch Ridge at Desert View

Girls Volleyball (Fr 4 p.m., JV 5 p.m., Var 6 p.m. unless otherwise noted)

Empire at Marana (4:30, 5:30, 6:30)

CDO at Queen Creek

Cienega at Mountain View

Sahuaro at Catalina Foothills

Walden Grove at Pusch Ridge

Thursday, September 18

Girls Golf

CDO, Ironwood Ridge at Phoenix Aguila Invitational (all day)

Boys Golf

Sahuaro and Salpointe at Ironwood Ridge

CDO, Rincon, Sunnyside at Tucson High

Girls Volleyball (Fr 4 p.m., JV 5 p.m., Var 6 p.m. unless otherwise noted)

Marana at Sahuarita

Ironwood Ridge at Sahuaro (4:30, 5:30, 6:30)

Catalina Foothills at Rincon

Pusch Ridge at San Manuel

Swimming (4 p.m.)

Marana vs. Tucson at Quincy Douglas Pool

Cienega at Marana

CDO, Ironwood Ridge at Amphi

Catalina Foothills at Sahuaro

Freshman Football (all games at 6 p.m. unless otherwise noted)

Flowing Wells at Marana (4 p.m.)

Desert View at Mountain View

Cienega at CDO

Ironwood Ridge at Buena

Catalina Foothills at Sahuarita

JV Football (all games at 6 p.m. unless otherwise noted)

Amphi at Marana

Santa Cruz Valley at Pusch Ridge

Mountain View at Desert View

CDO at Cienega

Buena at Ironwood Ridge

Sahuarita at Catalina Foothills

Friday, September 19

Boys Golf

Catalina Foothills, Ironwood Ridge, CDO, at Phoenix Aguila Invitational (all day)

Cross Country

Mountain View, Ironwood Ridge at Mt. Carmel Invitational (San Diego, CA)

Girls Volleyball

CDO at Westwood Tournament of Champions

Football (@7 p.m.)

Pusch Ridge at Santa Cruz Valley

Catalina at Marana

Desert Vista at Mountain View

Ironwood Ridge at Buena

Cienega at CDO

Catalina Foothills at Sahuarita

Saturday, September 20

Boys Golf

Catalina Foothills, Ironwood Ridge, CDO, at Phoenix Aguila Invitational (all day)

Cross Country

Marana at Old Pueblo Invite(Lincoln Park)

Mountain View at San Diego

Catalina Foothills, CDO at Ojo Rojo (Chandler, AZ)


Marana at Wolves Classic (Chandler High)

Girls Volleyball

CDO at Westwood Tournament of Champions


MOS: Storms and Floods

We asked the community about the coming floods and storms.

MOS: Back To School

We asked the community about the new school semester starting.

More Featured Videos

Follow us on Facebook